Reconnecting Communities Pilot Program

Completed in 1955, the Arlington Expressway and the conversion of State and Union Streets into arterial roads demolished hundreds of homes and cut Springfield and the Eastside off from Downtown.

On June 30, 2022, U.S. Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg announced that the Department of Transportation was accepting applications from communities for the new Reconnecting Communities Pilot Program. Funded Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill in November 2021, the program is aimed retrofitting or replacing transportation infrastructure like highways and railroads that has disrupted and severed neighborhoods. The initiative will invest $1 billion over the next five years into planning and construction of qualifying projects.

Jacksonville is one community with serious infrastructure needs that would benefit from this new investment, including many that would be a perfect fit for the goals of the Reconnecting Communities grant. As in other Southern cities, during the Jim Crow era highway planners used roadway infrastructure as a way to create physical boundaries between Black and white neighborhoods and to eliminate areas considered to be decaying. This, combined with disinvestment and redlining in Black neighborhoods at the time led to the destruction and decline of many of Jacksonville’s historic Black neighborhoods. Highways like the Jacksonville Expressway (now Interstate 95), Interstate 10, the 20th Street Expressway, the Haines Street Expressway and the Mathews Bridge Expressway plowed through neighborhoods and disconnected them from amenities and economic centers. Within years, homes that had been a short walk to shops, parks, libraries and schools found themselves cut off by roadways.

Jacksonville’s Jim Crow-era highway system led to a massive population decline across the Urban Core and contributed to Downtown’s collapse, as the city center was cut off from the residential neighborhoods that had long sustained it. Those highways still serve as physical barriers between historic neighborhoods and hold back Downtown and the Urban Core.

The deadline approaches

The Jacksonville Expressway – now I-95 – under construction in the 1950s. The highway was built through the heart of the African-American neighborhoods of LaVilla and Campbell Hill.

While Jacksonville has no shortage of projects that would qualify for the Reconnecting Communities grant, the clock is ticking. The Department of Transportation is only accepting applications for the pilot program until 11:59 PM EDT on Thursday, October 13, 2022. Unfortunately, the City of Jacksonville and the Jacksonville Transportation Authority have been silent about whether they will even submit applications, let alone what the projects would be.

Failing to apply for the Reconnecting Communities program would be a major missed opportunity. Will Jacksonville get it together in the next few weeks and apply for the grants? Or will we drop the ball on another opportunity to improve our outmoded infrastructure? The question is in our local leaders’ hands. In the meantime, we can offer five projects that could easily become top contenders for the funding.

Interstate 95 and LaVilla

Adjacent to the Downtown Northbank, LaVilla is one of Jacksonville’s oldest Gullah Geechee communities. Named after the LaVilla Plantation, LaVilla was established as a town of its own in 1866 by Francis F. L’Engle. Considered to Jacksonville’s oldest suburb, L’Engle served as LaVilla’s first mayor and by the time the community was annexed into Jacksonville in 1887, its population had increased to 3,000.

Anchored by Henry Flagler’s Jacksonville Terminal railroad station, LaVilla became a cultural exchange partner with New Orleans and emerged as a major epicenter for ragtime, jazz and blues during the early 20th century. According to the Indianapolis Freeman, the first published account of blues singing on a public stage occurred at LaVilla’s Colored Airdome on April 16, 1910. Following the 1920s Harlem Renaissance, LaVilla became known by some as the Harlem of the South. However, it was known as Uptown to the local African American community.

Starting in the 1930s, Jacksonville’s Black neighborhoods, like very many across the country, suffered from the discriminatory practice known as redlining. In practice, redlining resulted in Black communities like LaVilla being flagged as locales where banks specifically avoided investing and thus faced declining property values and home equity. Building on the legacy of redlining, one of the biggest monuments to racism in America and Jacksonville in the mid-20th century is the urban highway system. Locally, the expressway system developed by the Jacksonville Expressway Authority, the predecessor to the modern Jacksonville Transportation Authority (JTA), served as a major contributor to the ultimate decline of Downtown Jacksonville and several adjacent neighborhoods.

Proposed as early as 1945, Interstate 95’s route was locally determined by targeting historic African-American communities with suppressed property values due to redlining and systemic discriminatory local zoning practices. The route was also selected to serve as a form of urban renewal and to create a new physical racial demarcation line between then White and Black neighborhoods. Unsurprisingly, not much of LaVilla is left on the downtown side of Interstate 95. However, with the pending reconstruction of Interstate 95, now is the time to plan for infrastructure enhancements that can restore and strengthen severed connectivity within the LaVilla community.

Eastside, Emerald Trail & Union Street Expressway

Hogans Creek is a 2.6 mile long tidal creek that is prone to flooding, partially due to a culvert constructed as a part of the Union Street Expressway project during the 1950s. (Daniel Herbin)

Situated on land that was granted to Daniel Hogans in 1817, the Eastside is a collection of Gullah Geechee communities also known as Out East. Oakland, the oldest, was platted in 1869 by Jesse D. Cole. It was quickly settled by freedmen and women attracted by inexpensive housing and employment at the docks and sawmills along the riverfront. Many Gullah Geechee settlers resided in single and double tenement houses called shotgun homes. Built by African American architects and contractors, many of these wood-frame, tin-roofed structures include intricate woodwork along the eaves, similar to Victorian houses. Home to Old City Cemetery and the first public park established for Black residents in Jacksonville, well-known people who have lived in the Eastside include Abraham Lincoln Lewis, Zora Neale Hurston, A. Philip Randolph, and Robert “Bullet Bob” Hayes.

The Union Street Expressway near the Union Terminal Warehouse Company building and Hogans Creek. (Google Streetview)

Additional Eastside plats, including Campbell’s Addition and Longbranch, were developed during the 1880s, and Florida Avenue emerged as the major commercial thoroughfare east of Hogans Creek. The physical landscape of the neighborhood was dramatically altered by the construction of the Mathews Bridge and the Union Street Expressway. Built before the establishment of the Jacksonville Expressway Authority its path was selected along a line that served as the border between then white and African American neighborhoods in the Eastside. When the bridge opened in 1953, the first three thousand people attending the celebration received a free barbecue lunch. Downtown stores also promoted the bridge opening as a sales promotion to bring people to downtown. What was not recognized was the hundreds of Eastside property owners that lost their homes to eminent domain. This act also created the constrained culvert over Hogans Creek, contributing to the frequent flooding of the tidal waterway.

Today, the Eastside is engaged in a variety of “withintrification” strategies intended to protect the community against gentrification and displacement. The restoration of Hogans Creek and the reconstruction of the Union Street Expressway are two projects that can support these efforts. Groundwork Jacksonville has been working on restoring the 2.6-mile long tidal and freshwater creek as part of the Emerald Trail, a planned 30-mile network of bike and pedestrian paths linking various Jacksonville neighborhoods and institutions. Modern reconstruction of the out-of-date Union Street Expressway would be instrumental for reconnecting the Eastside community with its urban riverfront and resolving Hogans Creek flooding issues.

The Union Street Expressway at A. Philip Randolph Boulevard in the Eastside. (Google Streetview)

LaVilla’s Broad Street

Looking north down Broad Street and the streetcar tracks of the North Jacksonville Street Railway, Town and Improvement Company. Established in 1902 by several prominent members of Jacksonville’s Black community, the streetcar line connected LaVilla and Moncrief, creating the collection of neighborhoods now known as Mid-Westside. (State Archives of Florida)

If you travel down Broad Street in LaVilla today, you won’t pass by much that’s open. There was a time, however, when Broad was one of the urban core’s busiest retail districts, lined with furniture stores, restaurants, delis and shops. Historically, Broad was a two-way street and the city’s premier African American business district prior to desegregation. In 1980, the city of Jacksonville converted the street into one-way thoroughfare. The intention was to reduce traffic backups at rush hour caused by southbound cars needing to make left turns.

At the time, some Broad Street retailers were quite skeptical of the city’s changes to their street. They questioned the need for the project and expressed fear that it would hurt their businesses. “It is terrible,” said Morris Worman, owner of Worman’s Bakery and Delicatessen at the corner of Broad and Adams streets, in a contemporary Florida Times-Union article. “I do not see where this is going to help anything. I leave my store everyday at 5 o’clock and almost always in 10 minutes I am over the Acosta Bridge.” William Wall Jr., owner of Pierce-Wall Furniture Co. at 122 Bay St., expressed similar concerns. “Personally I feel it more helpful to business to have traffic both ways, so people can get to us. But it is hard to tell until it is done. All you can do is conjecture. As long as they do not take away parking.”

Henry Mock, the city traffic engineer, told the Times-Union there were no plans to take away parallel parking on the street. He said that parking would even be added in some stretches where it previously had been prohibited during rush hour. Morris Worman, however, predicted that street parking would soon be on the chopping block. “They will take away parking next,” he said. “They take away one finger at a time.” Worman’s finger-chopping prediction became reality when the Jacksonville Transportation Authority later replaced all on-street parking on both Broad and Jefferson Streets in favor of seldom-used dedicated bus lanes.

For his part, Henry Mock said the changes to the street wouldn’t hurt the struggling retailers. “Within 30 days, I think the merchants will think we have done them a favor,” he said. Unfortunately, time has proven the retailers right. LaVilla’s Broad Street has only continued to decline. Businesses shuttered and never reopened, and many more buildings were demolished, adding to the city’s vast collection of empty lots. Four decades later, there’s no parallel parking and no merchants either. With the on-going rapid redevelopment of Riverside Avenue in Brooklyn, Broad Street is a corridor where logical complete streets solutions should be embraced as a part of an effort to revitalize LaVilla.

LaVilla’s Broad Street in 2022 (Ennis Davis, AICP)

State & Union Streets

Looking was down Union Street from Pearl Street. (State Archives of Florida).

The original settlement of Hansontown was the brainchild of Daniel Dustin Hanson. Hanson, a surgeon with the 34th Regiment, U.S. Colored Infantry, acquired a large tract of land northwest of Jacksonville in 1866. His intentions were to develop the property into a communal farming community for Black Civil War veterans and freed slaves. Here, they would grow and sell crops, allowing them to pool their earnings towards land purchases. Due to his death in 1868, Hanson’s visions did fully materialize but the community, characterized by a divergent street grid, did attract residents. Largely built out by the turn-of-the-century, this working class community featured streets as narrow as 15’ wide, a small commercial center in the vicinity of State and Julia Streets, and several churches.

Nevertheless, Hansontown’s days were numbered by the time World War II came around. From its start, it had developed as a working class community for African-Americans. In segregated Jacksonville, its unpaved streets and frame shotgun houses were considered the slums. It quickly became an easy target for the city’s early urban renewal programs. During the 1940s and 1950s, large sections of Hansontown were targeted and removed for the construction of public housing projects and Interstate 95.

Still not happy about Hansontown’s existence, the City began to participate in the Federal urban renewal program after approval by the state legislature in 1969. With access to more federal money, Hansontown and neighboring areas were immediately targeted for wholesale redevelopment. For Hansontown, the Jacksonville Housing and Urban Development Department envisioned demolishing substandard housing on small lots and replacing them with townhouses, garden apartments and high-rise senior housing. In addition, the urban renewal project would replace Hansontown’s narrow 19th century street grid with new wide vehicle friendly streets.

At the heart of Hansontown, State and Union Streets were converted into a one-way pair of four lane thoroughfares to connect Interstate 95 with the Mathews Bridge and Arlington Expressway. Today, State and Union have become known as a dangerous, pedestrian hostile corridor that severs connectivity between Downtown Jacksonville and Springfield. As for Hansontown, it’s hard to believe there was a 19th century walkable community that the corridor once served. Although Hansontown is no longer with us today, the area represents a portion of the urban core that could be redeveloped with affordable, mixed-use development and missing middle housing served by real and reliable mass transit and multimodal friendly streets. To make this happen, a complete retrofit of State and Union Streets will be necessary.

Looking west on Union Street at Pearl Street on January 17, 1948. (State Archives of Florida)

Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Parkway

Originally the 20th Street Expressway, Martin Luther King Jr. Parkway was designed to limit the access through historic Black neighborhoods like Moncrief and Durkeeville, and served to allow white suburbanites to bypass the Urban Core during their commutes.

In 1891, African Methodist Episcopal (AME) pastor James William Randolph moved his family, wife Elizabeth and sons James, Jr. and Asa Philip Randolph, to Jacksonville as a part of a larger Black migration to southern cities in the decades following Emancipation. In 1892, Randolph began raising money for a new permanent AME church by organizing Saturday night fish and chicken fries. The congregation he established, first named New Hope AME Chapel and eventually renamed Greater New Hope AME Chapel, was built in a small African American community then known as Summerville.

The Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Parkway through Summerville. (Google Streetview)

Between 1961 and 1962, the Jacksonville Expressway Authority created a barrier between Summerville and the then White Brentwood neighborhood with the construction of the 20th Street Expressway. The result was the creation of a large network of dead end streets in what had originally been a collection of walkable neighborhoods with a well connected street grid. At the time, the 20th Street Expressway was designed to serve as a part of a northern bypass between Downtown Jacksonville and mid-20th century suburbs in Northwest Jacksonville. Prior to the expressway’s construction, 20th Street was a quaint street lined with single family and missing middle residences. In 2000, along with the Haines Street Expressway, the Jacksonville City Council voted to rename the two expressways after Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.

Regardless of the name, the 7.1-mile long thoroughfare and its miles of frontage roads, is a physical barrier that separates one time cohesive Eastside, Springfield and Northwest Jacksonville neighborhoods. Six decades after its initial construction, several portions of the highway are not designed to today’s standards. A prime candidate for future roadway improvement work, an opportunity exists to reimagine and revamp this corridor’s impact on the historic communities it was built through.

The Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Parkway through New Springfield. (Google Streetview)

Editorial by Ennis Davis and Bill Delaney.